Medical negligence and bile duct injuries

Medical Negligence and Injuries to the Bile Duct

Medical Negligence and Bile Duct Injuries

A study by the University of Oxford found that bile duct injury accounts for the largest proportion of negligence claims following laparoscopic cholecystectomy in the UK.

In the UK, claims for compensation in respect of bile duct injuries and hospital negligence frequently succeed (most commonly, by way of settlement out of court).  This study contained data from a 15 year period to 2009 and in this period, 65% of the cases studied were found in favour of the patient.  This study also reported that the average cost of compensation per patient was above £50,000.  In the USA, the findings are similar but the compensation amounts are much higher.

This study showed that opinions differed in relation to who was at fault in cases of bile duct injury. Poor decision making by medical professionals was the most commonly identified reason for bile duct injuries but almost half of research respondents identified factors outside the surgeon’s control as being the most important cause of bile duct injury.

Helen Coughlan
Medical Negligence Solicitor

Helen Coughlan is a partner and advises on medical negligence*, family law and personal injuries*. Helen is a qualified family mediator and collaborative law practitioner and is Chairperson of the Family and Child Law Committee of the Law Society.

Contact Helen Today

Gallstones – What Are They?

The Cleveland Clinic explains that the gallbladder is a small, sac-like organ that sits under the liver on the right side of your abdomen (belly). The gallbladder stores a greenish fluid called bile. Bile is made and released by the liver and then sent to the small intestine, where it helps the body break down and absorb food. Bile moves through a network of tube-like structures called bile ducts.

Gallstones are small stones that form in the gallbladder. Usually, they consist of cholesterol.  According to HSE data, if you have gallstones, in the majority of cases, you won’t need treatment and you won’t have any symptoms.

The risk of gallstones is higher if you are:

• Overweight
• Female (especially if you have children)
• Older than 40

When you have symptoms caused by gallstones, this is called gallstone disease or cholelithiasis.  The HSE advises that treatment is necessary if gallstones are causing:

• symptoms – such as abdominal pain
• complications – such as jaundice or acute pancreatitis

A HIQA report explains that the symptoms arising from sudden and complete obstruction of the cystic duct or the common bile duct by a stone is called ‘biliary colic’.

In some cases, you may need surgery to remove the gallbladder. This is often known as a laparoscopic cholecystectomy and the HSE note that there is generally a low risk of complications.  The Cleveland Clinic explains that the benefits of laparoscopic cholecystectomy (ie, keyhole surgery) over open surgery include less pain, less time in the hospital and quicker recovery. They state it is now considered the “gold standard” for surgical treatment of gallbladder disease.

The same report by HIQA noted that biliary calculi (that is, gallstones) are one of the most common surgical problems in the western world. Gallstone disease is the most common abdominal condition for which patients are admitted to hospital in developed countries.

Further, it states that gallstones are at least twice as common in women and that the increased risk in females begins at puberty and is increased further with the use of the oral contraceptive pill; while indicating that patients with a body mass index (BMI) greater than 40 Kg/m2 have shown a risk of developing gallstones that is eight times higher than those with a lower BMI.

If you would like to read further information on gallstones, click here.

Complications of Gall Bladder Surgery

The NHS in the UK reports that surgery to remove the gallbladder (also known as a cholecystectomy) is relatively safe procedure, but like all operations there’s a small risk of complications. Some of the possible complications are the following:

• Injury to the bile duct

During the operation to remove your gallbladder, your bile duct can be damaged.  Sometimes, the damage can be repaired straight away but in other cases, the damage can be more long lasting.

• Injury to the intestine and bowels

Similarly, your surrounding organs can be damaged as part of the surgery.

• Bile leakage

After the gallbladder is removed, sometimes bile fluid can leak into the abdomen.  Sometimes a further operation is required to drain this bile.

A HIQA report notes that the most serious complication of cholecystectomy (open and laparoscopic) is damage to the common bile duct.  It states that the incidence of bile duct injuries varies between 0.1% and 0.3%.  The report notes that other complications of cholecystectomy include bile leak, peritonitis requiring re-operation, postoperative bleeding requiring operation, and intraabdominal abscesses requiring operation. The laparoscopic approach is associated with a lower rate of surgical site infection when compared with the open procedure.

How to Tell If There Have Been Complications With Your Surgery

The NHS advises that it will usually take two weeks for you to return to your normal activities if you have a keyhole (or laparoscopic) surgery.  If you have an open procedure, it will take longer (around 6 to 8 weeks).  There can be temporary side effects from the surgery feeling sick or painful wounds.  However, the NHS advises you to contact your doctor if you experience the following as they could be a sign of a complication of the surgery:

• a return of your original symptoms
• severe, excessive or increasing pain
• a high temperature (fever) of 38C or above
• persistently feeling sick or vomiting
• increasing swelling, redness or discharge from a wound
• yellowing of the skin and whites of your eyes (jaundice)
• dark urine and pale stools

If you would like further information, click here.

Accidential Injuries to the Bile Duct

The Cleveland Clinic explains that during surgery, a bile duct can get cut, burned, or pinched. As a result of an injury, the bile duct will not be able to work right, leaking bile into the abdomen or blocking the normal flow of bile from the liver. Bile duct injuries lead to symptoms that can be painful and dangerous if not treated.

Some studies estimate that bile duct injuries occur in 1 in 1,000 cases of laparoscopic gallbladder surgery. They appear to occur less often in open surgeries.  The Cleveland Clinic notes that most bile duct injuries that occur during gallbladder surgery happen because the area around the gallbladder and bile ducts is masked in some way so that the doctor cannot see it clearly. This can happen if the area’s structure (anatomy) is different than normal, or if there is a lot of bleeding, swelling, or scarring in the area.

They say that some doctors think that using a test called intraoperative cholangiography (IOC) more often will help reduce the number, or severity, of bile duct injuries, while other doctors believe that not all injuries can be prevented, even with IOC. Other doctors suggest that changes in how the surgery is performed and the equipment used will reduce the number of injuries. However, not all bile duct injuries can be prevented, so they remain a possible risk of gallbladder surgery.

The University of Oxford study reported that factors that may contribute to bile duct injury include anatomic variation, severe inflammation, errors related to skill, knowledge or judgement of the medical professionals or demographic factors such as patient age or sex.

Consequences of a Bile Duct Injury

The Cleveland Clinic notes that the patient outcome depends on the type and extent of the injury and how soon the injury is found. Most bile duct injuries can be successfully repaired, and the patient can go on to have a good quality of life. In severe cases, with more than one surgery, many months of recovery might be needed.

How to Make a Bile Duct Injury Claim:

If you or a loved one has suffered from a bile duct injury as a result of medical negligence, you can take the following steps to pursue a claim:

Step 1: Seek Legal Advice

The first step in seeking compensation for a bile duct injury is to consult with a solicitor experienced in medical negligence and delayed diagnosis claims. They will guide you through the process and assess the merits of your case. An experienced solicitor will be able to determine your eligibility and advise you on the likelihood of your claim’s success.

Patrick J Farrell Solicitors specialise in the area of medical negligence, if you have been affected by a delayed diagnosis, don’t hesitate to contact us regarding your concerns and to receive expert advice. If you have suffered a bile duct injury, we can advise you on whether or not you may have a case.

We have acted in successful cases where our clients have suffered common bile duct injuries as part of laparoscopic cholecystectomies for gallstones.  The majority of these cases resulted in our client having to undergo further surgery to address the issue.  Our medical experts identified flaws in the surgery and aftercare and were often critical of the record keeping of the hospitals.  Lack of adequate record keeping is often a very frustrating element of the process for our clients as they try to establish what went wrong with their surgery.

Step 2: Gather Evidence

Your solicitor will request your complete medical records, which are crucial for supporting your claim of a delayed diagnosis. This includes your full medical records, any correspondence with the medical practice or practitioner, and other documentation related to your care. These pieces of evidence are essential for establishing that negligence occurred.

To support you in your claim, we can take up your medical records and obtain a medical report which will assess your injuries and examine whether anyone was at fault.  At that stage you can decide whether or not it is appropriate to proceed with a claim.  We have access to specialist medical consultants, generally in the UK, who will prepare these reports.

Step 3: Independent Medical Assessment

If necessary, you may need to have an independent medical expert evaluate your case and whether the care you received constituted negligence.

Step 4: Letter of Claim

Once your solicitor has gathered all necessary evidence, they will draft a Letter of Claim and notify the medical practice/practitioner that you intend to take a case against them. Your Letter of Claim outlines the details of your claim, the alleged cause of negligence leading to a delayed diagnosis, and the subsequent consequences for your health.

Step 5: Response and Resolution

The doctor or medical practice, through their own legal team, will respond to the Letter of Claim. They may accept responsibility and offer a settlement for any harm or suffering; or they may dispute the claim which will lead to further legal proceedings. Many claims are settled out of court. Your solicitor will negotiate on your behalf in order to receive fair compensation for your injuries, any costs incurred, and any future care needs.

However, if a settlement can’t be reached, your case could proceed to court where your solicitor will represent you in any court proceedings.

More Medical Negligence Resources

Medical Negligence Solicitors

Birth Injuries to Children

Birth Injuries to Mothers

Will Irish healthcare issues cause an increase in medical negligence claims?

Plastic Surgery and Cosmetic Procedures

Hip replacements and joint replacements